Explore My Family’s Favorite 4 Toy Stores in Guilford, CT

When you’re a parent, you spend a lot of time trying to find the perfect toys. Whether you’re buying for a birthday party or are trying to find the right item for your own child, you’re probably putting in a lot of thought as you stand in the toy aisles. If you are looking for quality products for better playtime, I would love to tell you about the best toy stores in Guilford, CT. With all these shops, you’ll have a fantastic item for every occasion.  

Treat Your Little Ones To Something New With These Toy Stores In Guilford, CT

Jordie’s Toy Shoppe

1100 Village Walk, Guilford, Connecticut 06437

Jordie’s Toy Shoppe was founded by parents Mickey and Lori Hershman back in 1986. This classic mom-and-pop toy store is one of three shops owned by the couple. While Jordie is the closest Guilford location, you owe it to yourself to try out their other two shops: Jesse’s Toys in Orange and Evan’s Toy Shoppe in Hamden. All three offer a thoughtful selection Mickey and Lori created with their own kids in mind. On top of offering brands like Playmobil and SmartMax, you’ll be greeted by passionate employees eager to help you find the best items for your needs.  When we lived in Hamden, Evan’s was our go-to.  Now we live in Guilford and love that location!  They carry many classic toy brands with much less plastic than a typical big box toy store.

Three blonde and smiling siblings sit on a large rock on the water hugging before visiting toy store guilford ct

Old Tyme Toys

314 Flat Rock Road Place B110, Westbrook, Connecticut 06498

If you’re a family who loves a good game night, you should stop by Old Tyme Toys! This Westbrook shop is loaded with games for all ages. You can find Sight Word Zingo to build up your child’s word recognition or try out an escape room-themed Adventure Game to work on your family’s teamwork. The shop also features puzzles, activity books, and mindful toys for younger kids. 

A mother lifts and laughs with her young daughter in her arms on the edge of some water in a park

Einstein’s Attic Madison

140 Samson Rock Drive, Madison, Connecticut 06443

Einstein’s Attic Madison only chooses toys designed to encourage your child’s imagination. Everything about this shop has been curated for your customer experience, from the free gift wrapping to the 100% satisfaction guarantee. The shop is full of open-ended play toys your child will love. They can build their own world with beautifully crafted wooden toys or create their own bakery with their pretend kitchen and food selection. Plus, the shop’s dress-up section is simply out of this world!  It’s the perfect place to find a cherished gift.

A happy father in a grey sweater stands in a park snuggling with his toddler daughter on his hip before visiting toy store guilford ct

Elm City Games

71 Orange Street, New Haven, Connecticut 06510

For over 8 years, Elm City Games has been helping individuals find their perfect game. The shop always stays stocked with games for all ages. You’ll find Magic the Gathering sets, Settlers of Catan expansions, and Star Wars-themed card sets. They sell locally made games you can’t find anywhere else. The best thing about the shop is that there’s always something going on, from Monday Jigsaw Puzzle Clubs to their Friday Party Games nights.  Plus while you’re in New Haven you can grab lunch or visit a local museum with your child for a fun outing for everyone!

Your Family With Love Every Visit To These Toy Stores In Guilford, CT

With these fantastic Guilford, CT toy stores, you’ll always have the perfect gift. Stop by today so you can get to shopping! 

If you’re looking for more recommendations, I would love it if you stuck around! I’m a Connecticut family photographer, and I am constantly trying to find new ways to support local families. From telling you about my favorite Connecticut shops to helping you plan family photo sessions, I’m here for it all! If you’ve been considering booking a photo session for your crew, I would love to have a conversation so you can decide if I’m the photographer for you. Let’s chat soon!

Serving Guilford, New Haven County, Connecticut, & beyond